以数字技术助推城市基层治理是基层治理创新的重要理论及实践议题。在技术与组织“互构论”视角下构建“结构嵌入—行为吸纳”分析框架,结合上海市H街道“数字孪生城市”案例,研究发现:数字技术通过结构嵌入与行为吸纳两种机制助推城市基层治理,且在结构嵌入过程中与客观制度规范、权力结构、条块关系等结构要素“互构”,在行为吸纳过程中与主观思维理念、行为方式、治理能力等行为要素“互构”。同时,在“互构”过程中存在技术迭代与制度保障对称性不足、技术嵌入与部门壁垒张力明显、技术赋能与基层管理者能力矛盾突出等现实困境。未来应促进技术发展与制度变革互惠共生、技术嵌入与条块关系耦合互动、技术赋能与基层管理者能力平衡互配。
It is an important theoretical and practical issue to promote urban grassroots governance innovation with digital technology. From the perspective of the “mutual structure theory” of technology and organization, the analysis framework of “structural embeddedness - behavioral absorption” is constructed. Combined with the case study of the “digital twin city” of Shanghai's H Subdistrict, it is found that digital technology promotes urban grassroots governance through two mechanisms of structural embeddedness and behavioral absorption, and in the process of structural embeddedness, digital technology “interconstructs” with objective institutional norms, power structure, block relationship and other structural elements. In the process of behavior absorption, it “interconstructs” with subjective thinking concept, behavior mode, governance ability and other behavior elements. At the same time, in the process of “mutual construction”, practical difficulties exist such as insufficient symmetry of technology iteration and institutional guarantee, obvious tension between technology embedment and departmental barriers, and prominent contradiction between technology empowerment and the ability of grassroots managers. Therefore, in the future, it is necessary to promote the mutualism between technology development and institutional change, the coupling and interaction between technology embedment and the relationship between blocks, and the balanced and mutual matching between technology empowerment and the ability of grassroots managers.
[1] 陈天祥,蓝云,胡友芳.双重嵌入:以数字技术打破基层治理中的条块分割[J].江苏行政学院学报,2023(1):111-119
[2] 李忠汉.数字治理驱动治理重心下移的机制分析——以北京市“接诉即办”改革为例[J].北京社会科学,2022(11):25-33
[3] 陈天祥,徐雅倩,宋锴业,等.双向激活:基层治理中的数字赋能——“越秀越有数”数字政府建设的经验启示[J].华南师范大学学报(社会科学版),2021(4):87-100,206-207
[4] 吴新星.数字技术赋能城市基层治理的行动障碍与突破策略——基于S市G区F街道数字治理创新实践的参与式观察[J].河南社会科学,2022(6):82-91
[5] 邓念国.整体智治:城市基层数字治理的理论逻辑与运行机制——基于杭州市S镇的考察[J].理论与改革,2021(4):58-69,155-156
[6] 彭勃,刘旭.用数字化兜住模糊性事务:基层治理的技术赋能机制[J].学海,2022(3):48-56
[7] 王志立,刘祺.数字赋能市域社会治理现代化的逻辑与路径[J].中州学刊,2023(2):73-81
[8] 盛明科,贺清波.数字技术治理风险的生成与防治路径探析——以技术与制度互构论为视角[J].湘潭大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2023(2):16-23
[9] [美]简·E·芳汀著,邵国松译.构建虚拟政府:信息技术与制度创新[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2010:21
[10] 邱泽奇.技术与组织的互构——以信息技术在制造企业的应用为例[J].社会学研究,2005(2):32-54,243
[11] 吴晓林.技术赋能与科层规制——技术治理中的政治逻辑[J].广西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2020(2):73-81
[12] 沈费伟.技术嵌入与制度吸纳:提高政府技术治理绩效的运作逻辑[J].自然辩证法通讯,2021(2):80-86
[13] 庞锐.制度弹性:技术治理刚性风险的生成逻辑与化解路径——基于城市网格化管理的比较案例分析[J].中国行政管理,2022(5):73-80
[14] 唐京华.数字技术驱动科层组织领域化运作的逻辑——基于浙江“基层治理四平台”的案例分析[J].治理研究,2023(1):40-52,158
[15] 余敏江,方熠威.“隐秩序”画像:城市精细化治理的机制设计——以复杂适应系统理论为分析视角[J].求实,2022(6):58-74,109
[16] 刘祺.技术赋能、结构重塑与制度创新:基层数字政府改革的逻辑[J].中共天津市委党校学报,2022(6):64-73
[17] 张燕,邱泽奇.技术与组织关系的三个视角[J].社会学研究,2009(2):200-215,246