城市科学

21世纪以来城市公共交通服务质量研究进展及展望——基于国内外文献的系统回顾

  • 郭亮 ,
  • 刘畅 ,
  • 范在予 ,
  • 孙小丽
展开
郭亮(1971—),男,湖北应城人,华中科技大学建筑与城市规划学院教授,博士研究生导师,博士,主要研究方向为绿色交通与城乡空间发展、可持续城乡规划设计理论与方法、城市交通与土地利用一体化;范在予(1994—),男,湖南汝城人,华中科技大学建筑与城市规划学院博士研究生,主要研究方向为城市空间结构与交通;孙小丽(1972—),女,湖北武汉人,武汉市交通发展战略研究院总工程师,正高级工程师,主要研究方向为轨道交通工程、交通模型、综合交通规划。
刘畅(1994—),男,湖北孝感人,华中科技大学建筑与城市规划学院博士研究生,主要研究方向为城市公共交通规划、城市交通与出行行为

收稿日期: 2024-02-21

  修回日期: 2024-03-27

  网络出版日期: 2024-05-15

基金资助

国家自然科学基金项目(52178039)——“基于通勤绩效提升的大城市空间结构优化——以武汉为例”。

Research progress and prospects of urban public transportation service quality since the 21st century: A systematic review based on domestic and international literature

  • GUO Liang and Colleagues
Expand

Received date: 2024-02-21

  Revised date: 2024-03-27

  Online published: 2024-05-15

摘要

在系统梳理2000—2023年城市公共交通服务质量评价及提升研究相关文献的基础上,通过内容分析法揭示国内外研究概况及其异同,并进一步结合文档分析法进行归纳与总结。研究发现:国内外相关文献在研究主题与内容特征方面存在不同偏好,而乘客满意度是当前共同关注的研究热点。政府、企业与公众分别是宏观研究和微观研究的主流评价主体,评价指标聚焦于感知服务与客观性能两大体系,两者之间具有可测度的关联特征,多式联运与空间环境是评价指标体系侧重改进的方向,位置服务数据与满意度分别是评价方法的介入点。内部改进与模式互补是提升策略涉及的主要措施,重要性一绩效表现分析与三因素理论模型是应对难点的有效探索方案。未来研究应重点加强对空间环境评价指标的关注,利用互联网大数据丰富评价方法,探索基于空间视阈的服务质量提升途径。

本文引用格式

郭亮 , 刘畅 , 范在予 , 孙小丽 . 21世纪以来城市公共交通服务质量研究进展及展望——基于国内外文献的系统回顾[J]. 城市问题, 2024 , 345(4) : 17 -30 . DOI: 10.13239/j.bjsshkxy.cswt.240402

Abstract

This study systematically reviews literature on the evaluation and enhancement of urban public transportation service quality from 2000 to 2023. Employing content analysis, it reveals the similarities and differences in domestic and international literature, further synthesizing details through document analysis. The findings indicate divergent preferences in research themes and content characteristics globally, with passenger satisfaction emerging as a current focal point of interest. Government and corporate entities, along with the public, serve as the primary perspectives for macro and micro-level research, respectively. The evaluation content concentrates on two major systems: perceived service and objective performance, both exhibiting measurable interrelations. Multi-modal integration and spatial environment are prioritized directions for improving evaluation indices, with location-based services and satisfaction metrics serving as pivotal points of methodological intervention. Internal improvements and modal complementarity constitute the main strategies for enhancement, while Importance-Performance Analysis and the Three-Factor Theory model represent effective exploratory solutions to address challenges. Future research should focus on incorporating spatial environmental indices, enriching evaluation methods with internet big data, and exploring service quality enhancement pathways based on spatial perspectives.

参考文献

[1] 美国交通运输研究委员会编著,杨晓光,滕靖等译.公共交通通行能力和服务质量手册[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2010:73-79
[2] Ojo T K. Quality of public transport service: An integrative review and research agenda[J]. Transportation Letters-the International Journal of Transportation Research, 2019(11): 104-116
[3] Jaiswal A, Manoj M, Tiwari G. A review of studies on service quality of intermediate public transport[J]. IATSS Research, 2022(46): 537-546
[4] 胡雨婷,张春勤,刘勇.常规地面公共交通服务质量评价文献综述[J].浙江理工大学学报(自然科学版),2020(43):136-144
[5] Abu Bakar M F, Norhisham S, Katman H Y, et al. Service quality of bus performance in Asia: A systematic literature review and conceptual framework[J]. Sustainability, 2022(14): 7998
[6] 包家烁,唐鹏程,张晓光,等.城市公共交通服务满意度评价研究进展[J].湖南城市学院学报(自然科学版),2022(31):48-52
[7] Roberts C, Grisé E, van Lierop D. Advances in Transport Policy and Planning[M].Salt Lake City: Academic Press, 2021: 211-242
[8] Van Lierop D, Badami M G, El-Geneidy A M. What influences satisfaction and loyalty in public transport? A review of the literature[J]. Transport Reviews, 2018(38): 52-72
[9] 张春勤,隽志才,刘志凯.公共交通服务绩效评价研究综述[J].计算机应用研究,2015(32):1-5,34
[10] 毛保华,王敏,何天健,等.城市公共交通服务水平研究回顾和展望[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2022(22):2-13
[11] Tranfield D, Denyer D, Smart P. Towards a methodology for developing evidence-informed management knowledge by means of systematic review[J]. British Journal of Management, 2003(14): 207-222
[12] Eboli L, Mazzulla G. A new customer satisfaction index for evaluating transit service quality[J]. Journal of Public Transportation, 2009(12): 21-37
[13] De Oña J, de Oña R. Quality of service in public transport based on customer satisfaction surveys: A review and assessment of methodological approaches[J]. Transportation Science, 2015(49): 605-622
[14] 王欢明,李鹏.公交服务公众满意度的影响因素及测度[J].城市问题,2015(5):77-84
[15] Zhang C, Juan Z, Lu W, et al. Do the organizational forms affect passenger satisfaction? Evidence from Chinese public transport service[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2016(94): 129-148
[16] 王欢明,诸大建.我国城市公交服务治理模式与运营效率研究——以长三角城市群公交服务为例[J].公共管理学报,2011(2):52-62,126
[17] 谷素斐,张红云.城市轨道交通客运服务质量综合评价应用研究[J].都市快轨交通,2020(33):123-128
[18] 房德威,王雪,孙珊.基于IPA-Kano模型的地面公交服务质量优化对策——以哈尔滨市为例[J].科学技术与工程,2020(20):13454-13459
[19] Dell’Olio L, Ibeas A, Cecin P. The quality of service desired by public transport users[J]. Transport Policy, 2011(18): 217-227
[20] Singh H, Kathuria A. Heterogeneity in passenger satisfaction of bus rapid transit system among age and gender groups: A PLS-SEM multi-group analysis[J]. Transport Policy, 2023(141): 27-41
[21] Ravensbergen L, Varickanickal J, Newbold K B, et al. A mixed-methods investigation of older adults’ public transit use and travel satisfaction[J]. Travel Behaviour and Society, 2023(32): 100577
[22] Mandhani J, Nayak J K, Parida M. Should I travel by metro? Analyzing the service quality perception of elderly and physically disabled passengers in Delhi, India[J]. Transportation Research Record, 2023(9): 265-278
[23] De Oña J, Estévez E, de Oña R. Public transport users versus private vehicle users: Differences about quality of service, satisfaction and attitudes toward public transport in Madrid (Spain)[J]. Travel Behaviour and Society, 2021(23): 76-85
[24] 纪江明,胡伟.我国城市公共交通公众满意度的影响因素研究——基于“2012连氏中国城市公共服务质量调查”的实证分析[J].软科学,2015(29):10-14
[25] Sun F, Jin M, Zhang T, et al. Satisfaction differences in bus traveling among low-income individuals before and after COVID-19[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2022(160): 311-332
[26] 霍月英,李文权,李晓娟,等.快速公交服务水平模糊分级方法[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版),2020(41):1509-1516
[27] Deepa L, Mondal A, Raman A, et al. An analysis of individuals’ usage of bus transit in Bengaluru, India: Disentangling the influence of unfamiliarity with transit from that of subjective perceptions of service quality[J]. Travel Behaviour and Society, 2022(29): 1-11
[28] Munim Z H, Noor T. Young people’s perceived service quality and environmental performance of hybrid electric bus service[J]. Travel Behaviour and Society, 2020(20): 133-143
[29] Allen J, Munoz J C, de Dios Ortuzar J. On the effect of operational service attributes on transit satisfaction[J]. Transportation, 2020(47): 2307-2336
[30] 高硕遥,陈维亚,王子超.有轨电车服务质量评价方法[J].城市轨道交通研究,2020(23):132-136
[31] Díez-Mesa F, de Oña R, de Oña J. Bayesian networks and structural equation modelling to develop service quality models: Metro of Seville case study[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2018(118): 1-13
[32] David E, Kurt F, Scheier B, et al. Optimization of DRT concepts using the SUMO simulation software: How can the service quality be improved?[C]. TRA Lisbon 2022 Conference Proceedings Transport Research Arena. 2023: 3972-3978
[33] Rahman F, Das T, Hadiuzzaman M, et al. Perceived service quality of paratransit in developing countries: A structural equation approach[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2016(93): 23-38
[34] Kumar S, Sinha S. Willingness to pay for improvement in service quality of intermediate public transport (IPT) modes[J]. Civil Engineering Journal-Tehran, 2021(7): 866-879
[35] De Ona J, de Ona R. Is it possible to attract private vehicle users towards public transport? Understanding the key role of service quality, satisfaction and involvement on behavioral intentions[J]. Transportation, 2023(50): 1073-1101
[36] Parasuraman A, Zeithaml V A, Berry L L. A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1985(49): 41-50
[37] Hensher D. Service quality as a package: What does it mean to heterogeneous consumers?[C]. 9th World Congress on Transport Research. 2003: 1-20
[38] 周雪梅,石云林,刘梅,等.城乡公交服务质量评价方法[J].同济大学学报(自然科学版),2015(43):1031-1038
[39] Eboli L, Mazzulla G. A methodology for evaluating transit service quality based on subjective and objective measures from the passenger’s point of view[J]. Transport Policy, 2011(18): 172-181
[40] Eboli L, Mazzulla G. Performance indicators for an objective measure of public transport service quality[J]. European Transport-Trasporti Europei, 2012(51): 1-4
[41] 武慧荣,崔淑华,张海松.基于乘客感知的城市公交服务质量评价研究[J].重庆交通大学学报(自然科学版),2012(31):1027-1030
[42] De Oña J, de Oña R, Eboli L, et al. Perceived service quality in bus transit service: A structural equation approach.[J]. Transport Policy, 2013(29): 219-226
[43] Echaniz E, dell’Olio L, Ibeas Á. Modelling perceived quality for urban public transport systems using weighted variables and random parameters[J]. Transport Policy, 2018(67): 31-39
[44] Tumsekcali E, Ayyildiz E, Taskin A. Interval valued intuitionistic fuzzy AHP-WASPAS based public transportation service quality evaluation by a new extension of SERVQUAL Model: P-SERVQUAL 4.0.[J]. Expert Systems with Applications, 2021(186): 115757
[45] Ong A K S, Agcaoili T I F, Juan D E R, et al. Utilizing a machine learning ensemble to evaluate the service quality and passenger satisfaction among public transportations[J]. Journal of Public Transportation, 2023(25): 100076
[46] Nathanail E. Measuring the quality of service for passengers on the Hellenic railways[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2008(42): 48-66
[47] Carrel A, Mishalani R G, Sengupta R, et al. In pursuit of the happy transit rider: Dissecting satisfaction using daily surveys and tracking data[J]. Journal of Intelligent Transportation Systems, 2016(20): 345-362
[48] Rong R, Liu L, Jia N, et al. Impact analysis of actual traveling performance on bus passenger’s perception and satisfaction[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2022(160): 80-100
[49] De Oña J. Understanding the mediator role of satisfaction in public transport: A cross-country analysis.[J]. Transport Policy, 2021(100): 129-149
[50] 刘冬梅,荣建,张劲泉,等.面向公交全出行链的短时服务评价模型研究[J].公路交通科技,2018(35):123-133
[51] Diana M. Measuring the satisfaction of multimodal travelers for local transit services in different urban contexts[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2012(46): 1-11
[52] 温惠英,邓艳辉.公交出行各阶段时间对多群组乘客满意度的影响[J].广西大学学报(自然科学版),2019 (44):1195-1206
[53] 乔相荣,姜珊,巩舜妹,等.考虑出行者感知的城市轨道交通接驳服务评价[J].城市轨道交通研究,2020(23):40-43,49
[54] Zacharias J, Liu X. The role of the access environment in metro commute travel satisfaction[J]. Sustainability, 2022(14): 15322
[55] Park K, Farb A, Chen S. First-/last-mile experience matters: The influence of the built environment on satisfaction and loyalty among public transit riders[J]. Transport Policy, 2021(112): 32-42
[56] Wu W, Yao Y, Wang R. Green space exposure at subway stations, transportation mode choice and travel satisfaction[J]. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 2023(122): 103862
[57] Wu I C, Lin Y C. Evaluation of space service quality for facilitating efficient operations in a mass rapid transit station[J]. Sustainability, 2020(12):5295
[58] Wang J, Cao X, Liu K, et al. Exploring the nonlinear effects of built environment characteristics on customized bus service[J]. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 2023(114): 103523
[59] Maharjan S, Tsurusaki N, Divigalpitiya P. Influencing mechanism analysis of urban form on travel energy consumption—Evidence from Fukuoka city, Japan[J]. Urban Science, 2018(2): 15
[60] 徐以群,陈茜.城市公共交通服务水平的指标体系[J].城市交通,2006(6):42-46
[61] 杨晓光,安健,刘好德,等.公交运行服务质量评价指标体系探讨[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2010(4):13-21
[62] 冯国强,王天乐,赵昆.提升地铁—公交车接驳率的治堵效应——基于昆明市交通网络大数据的分析[J]. 城市问题,2021(11):70-78
[63] Sukhov A, Lättman K, Olsson L E, et al. Assessing travel satisfaction in public transport: A configurational approach.[J]. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 2021(93): 102732
[64] Li X H, Huang L, Li Q, et al. Passenger satisfaction evaluation of public transportation using Pythagorean Fuzzy Multimoora Method under large group environment[J]. Sustainability, 2020(12): 4996
[65] Echaniz E, Ho C, Rodriguez A, et al. Modelling user satisfaction in public transport systems considering missing information[J]. Transportation, 2020(47): 2903-2921
[66] Kutlu Gündodu F, Duleba S, Moslem S, et al. Evaluating public transport service quality using Picture Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process and Linear Assignment Model[J]. Applied Soft Computing, 2021(100): 106920
[67] Tomas Mendez J, Lobel H, Parra D, et al. Using Twitter to infer user satisfaction with public transport: The case of Santiago, Chile[J]. IEEE Access, 2019(7): 60255-60263
[68] Qi B, Costin A, Jia M. A framework with efficient extraction and analysis of Twitter data for evaluating public opinions on transportation services[J]. Travel Behaviour and Society, 2020(21): 10-23
[69] Tuan V A, Van Truong N, Tetsuo S, et al. Public transport service quality: Policy prioritization strategy in the importance-performance analysis and the three-factor theory frameworks[J]. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 2022(166): 118-134
[70] 陈维亚,李嘉佳,康梓轩.考虑可执行度的地铁服务质量提升策略研究[J].铁道科学与工程学报,2022(19):2090-2099
[71] 姚迪,徐丽群,李金培.公交服务水平、交通需求管理与公交吸引力——基于客观选择与主观意愿的双重检验[J].系统管理学报,2020(29): 31-40
[72] Martilla J A, James J C. Importance-performance Analysis[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1977(41): 77-79
[73] Cao J, Cao X. Comparing importance-performance analysis and three-factor theory in assessing rider satisfaction with transit[J]. Journal of Transport and Land Use, 2017(10): 837-854
[74] Kano N, Seraku N, Takahashi F, et al. Attractive quality and must-be quality[J]. Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control, 1984(31): 147-156
[75] 吴玲玲,黄正东.基于多样性的大城市公共交通服务水平研究[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2019(19):222-227
[76] Echaniz E, Cordera R, Rodriguez A, et al. Spatial and temporal variation of user satisfaction in public transport systems[J]. Transport Policy, 2022(117): 88-97
文章导航

/

〈 〉